This has been a staple of my fall riding in NYC from 40 up to 60 degrees Farenheit. It's sleek and does great in the city.
I ordered this to be a snug fit. It's a very stretchy material that breathes really well. It mysteriously holds in just enough heat. I dig it.
The Magic Shell jacket works just as advertised so far this fall season for me. I purposely sized up to large (Ornot medium jerseys and t-shirts fit me perfectly at 5'8", 150) because I prefer a looser jacket fit for different levels of layering. I'm sure the medium would fit me fine with a more snug fit. Completely windproof and I have only worn it a couple of times in a light rain but it kept me dry. It has a great feel and look and is quiet as well. I bought the black and have even worn it with jeans for walks around the park. Everything feels quality, zippers work well one handed. I put a small zipper pull on the rear pocket. Can grab it easily with gloves now. Happy customer!